Agenda and minutes

North Planning Committee - Tuesday, 5th October, 2010 7.00 pm

Venue: Committee Room 5 - Civic Centre. View directions

Contact: Natasha Dogra 

Items
No. Item

24.

Apologies for Absence

Minutes:

None.

25.

Declarations of Interest in matters coming before this meeting

Minutes:

None.

26.

To sign and receive the minutes of the 5th August and 26th August meetings. pdf icon PDF 208 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The minutes were agreed as an accurate record.

27.

Matters that have been notified in advance or urgent

Minutes:

No matters had been notified in advance or as urgent.

28.

To confirm that the items of business marked Part 1 will be considered in public and that the items marked Part 2 will be considered in private

Minutes:

All items on the agenda were marked Part I and were considered in public.

29.

12 Eastbury Road, Northwood 1901/APP/2010/244 pdf icon PDF 175 KB

Part two storey, part single storey front extension with 1 side rooflight, first floor side/rear extension to include 3 side dormers and 3 side rooflights, with external staircase to rear to provide additional bedrooms and alterations to existing, external alterations and new landscaping (involving demolition of bay window to ground floor rear, part first floor external wall and part of the west elevation wall).

 

Minutes:

In accordance with the Council’s constitution a representative of the petition received in support of the proposal was invited to address the meeting.

 

Points raised by the petitioner:

  • The building was Locally Listed and within the Northwood Conservation Area.
  • The proposed extension would be unduly intrusive.
  • The proposed design would not be in keeping with the area’s character and so would look out of place.
  • The side dormers appeared to be too large.
  • The proposed fire escape was unsightly and intrusive
  • The proposed boundary hedging appeared to be insufficient.
  • The site would infringe on the privacy of surrounding residents.

 

Members commended Officers on a very comprehensive report. Members highlighted their concerns over the proposed design of the staircase – Officers directed Members to the addendum sheet where the staircase was included as a reason (6) for refusal. The Committee agreed that the proposed site would be unsettling for residents.

 

It was moved and seconded that the application be refused. On being put to the vote, the Committee agreed refusal unanimously.

 

Resolved – That the application be refused as per the Officers’ recommendation and as per the addendum.

30.

12 Eastbury Road, Northwood 1901/APP/2010/245 pdf icon PDF 139 KB

Demolition of bay window to ground floor rear, part first floor external wall, part of the west elevation wall and several internal walls (Application for Conservation Area Consent).

 

Minutes:

Officers presented this reported jointly with Item 6 on the agenda.

 

It was moved and seconded that the application be refused. On being put to the vote, the Committee agreed refusal unanimously.

 

Resolved – That the application be refused as per the Officers’ recommendation and as per the addendum.

 

31.

MOD Eastcote, Lime Grove, Ruislip 10189/APP/2009/1117 pdf icon PDF 242 KB

Details of off-site highway works in compliance with condition 40 of planning permission ref.10189/APP/ 2007/3383 dated 21/02/2008: Redevelopment for residential purposes at a density of up to 50 dwellings per hectare.

 

Minutes:

Officers presented their report to the Committee. Officers’ addendum suggested the additional of the following paragraphs:

 

'Waiting Restrictions at Lime Grove:

 

Waiting restrictions along Lime Grove formed part of the outline planning permission for the redevelopment of the RAF site. The waiting restrictions were required as previously two way traffic was impaired due to parked cars and there was ad hoc shuttle parking. This was regularised by the introduction of waiting restrictions at predetermined stretches of the highway. The waiting restrictions are from 8:00-9:00 am and 4:30-6:30 pm and double yellow lines at junctions.

 

These works were secured by the S106 Agreement attached to the outline consent and Condition 40 of that permission. The requisite public consultations were carried out and the necessary traffic orders were made. The works have been carried out in accordance with the S106 and 278 Agreements.'

 

It was moved and seconded that the application be approved. On being put to the vote, the Committee agreed approval unanimously.

 

Resolved – That the application be approval as per the Officers’ recommendation and as per the addendum.

 

32.

MOD Eastcote, Lime Grove, Ruislip 10189/APP/2010/168 pdf icon PDF 109 KB

Details of pedestrian crossing in compliance with condition 20 of planning permission ref.10189/APP/ 2007/2954 dated 03/03/2008: Proposed new access road from Eastcote Road to the boundary of R.A.F. Eastcote to facilitate the redevelopment of R.A.F. Eastcote for residential purposes.

 

Minutes:

Officers presented this reported jointly with Item 9 on the agenda.

 

It was moved and seconded that the application be approved. On being put to the vote, the Committee agreed approval unanimously.

 

Resolved – That the application be approval as per the Officers’ recommendation and as per the addendum.

 

33.

63 Lime Grove, Eastcote 27575/APP/2010/1983 pdf icon PDF 144 KB

Erection of 3, four-bedroom, three storey terrace dwellings involving the demolition of existing dwelling.

 

Minutes:

Officers presented their report to the Committee.

 

It was moved and seconded that the application be refused. On being put to the vote, the Committee agreed refusal unanimously.

 

Resolved – That the application be refused as per the Officers’ recommendation and as per the addendum.

 

34.

66 Long Lane, Ickenham 39319/APP/2010/1601 pdf icon PDF 230 KB

Erection of two storey building with habitable accommodation in the roof space, containing 7 two bedroom flats (amendment to previously approved scheme 39319/APP/2007/171 dated 10-12-2007 - including 2 new rear dormers)

 

Minutes:

Officers presented their report to the Committee.

 

It was moved and seconded that the application be approved. On being put to the vote, the Committee agreed approval unanimously.

 

Resolved – That the application be approval as per the Officers’ recommendation and as per the addendum.

 

35.

66 Long Lane, Ickenham 39319/APP/2010/1602 pdf icon PDF 132 KB

Demolition of existing house and garage (in connection with proposal to redevelop site for 7 x 2-bedroom flats) (Application for Conservation Area Consent)

 

Minutes:

Officers presented their report to the Committee.

 

It was moved and seconded that the application be approved. On being put to the vote, the Committee agreed approval unanimously.

 

Resolved – That the application be approval as per the Officers’ recommendation and as per the addendum.

 

36.

Ruislip Nursing Home,173 West End Road, Ruislip 19817/APP/2010/1703 pdf icon PDF 204 KB

Single storey side extension and part single storey, part two storey rear extension, involving demolition of existing conservatory to rear and staff room to side.

 

Minutes:

Officers presented their report to the Committee. As a matter of clarity the Committee asked Officers to specify the number of cycle spaces made available on site – which would be 10. Members asked Officers to include a condition relating to the use of power-point vehicles. Planning Officers agreed to include a condition relating to the use of power-point vehicles and would agree the wording with the Chairman and Labour Lead.

 

The Committee agreed that the proposed design would make the site look neater. Officers informed Members that the additional bedrooms would be en suites. Officers also informed Members that the building material samples would be agreed with Officers.

 

Members agreed the following additional conditions:

 

1. Condition 2 (M2 External materials to match) to be replaced with M1 (Samples to be submitted).

 

2. Additional condition to be added, the wording of which to be agreed with conservative and labour leads, requiring details of a charging point and parking/storage for motorised wheelchairs/scooters.

 

It was moved and seconded that the application be approved. On being put to the vote, the Committee agreed approval unanimously.

 

Resolved – That the application be approval as per the Officers’ recommendation with additional conditions and as per the addendum.

 

37.

Priors Farm, West End Road, Ruislip 14699/APP/2010/1493 pdf icon PDF 172 KB

Single storey side extension to existing cattle yard.

Minutes:

Officers presented their report to the Committee.

 

It was moved and seconded that the application be approved. On being put to the vote, the Committee agreed approval unanimously.

 

Resolved – That the application be approval as per the Officers’ recommendation and as per the addendum.

 

38.

Any Items Transferred from Part 1

Minutes:

None.

39.

Any Other Business in Part 2

Minutes:

None.